Update for the rolling changes coming MAR-023
With the incoming changes in maximum jump mass the rolling META has changed slightly:
- For 1m mass holes, you can now roll effectively with any battleship. This will make the Hyperion another strong Combat Roller, and Typhoons will be slightly faster than Tempests for Speed Rollers.
- For 2m mass holes, having a Battleship just over 100k mass will reduce the chance of needing a HIC from around 1% with the old setups to 0%. Thus using plates or heavier Battleships is now META. I suggest looking at Hyperions and Typhoons as well.
There is a theoretical setup to roll with 360k (hot) mass Battleships with 6 hot jumps which only needs 3 characters. This will close the Hole with a 96% chance. (4% chance you need a HIC), however you don’t have a safety margin, so any additional mass on the hole increases your chance to roll something out. This mass can be reached with Armageddons and a lot of T2 1600mm plates that have been abyssal rolled for max mass, as well as not training Armor Layering. Setups like this will be very slow when reapproaching the wormhole and are probably not worth it for most people.
- For 3m mass holes, using heavier ships will start to build a chance you roll a Battleship out, so sub 100k mass Battleships are still preferred. I did not do the math on heavier ships, but it is certainly possible somehow.
- For 5m holes, you should already be better at calculating than then I am.
This is one of the most used ships in Wormhole space, and while the basics are always the same, there is a lot of different ways you can fly them and make them work. Everyone has an opinion on what the best possible Roller is, so I am not going to argue that. But I want to explain a few categories that allow for effective definitions of “best” and therefore for a clear solution.
These ones are quite simple, you just want the maximum possible speed for rolling. The meta here is generally well known, you either run a cheap Tempest or a more expensive Machariel. You don’t expect to live very long when engaged, and just want to maximize your utility to maybe still get out of a sticky situation. You want to fit
- Higgs Anchor
- MWD (To get back fast)
- AB (To do your duty when you are scrambled)
- MJD (To Escape)
- Cloak (To stay at holes/escape)
- Probe Launcher (Because nobody is perfect)
- Overdrives / Hyperspatials / Inertial Stabilizers (to be fast)
- Burst Jammer (to disable tackle)
- Neuts / Smartbombs (to disable tackle)
We will not consider any kind of tank modules in this first part, I will explain later why. This generally comes down to two questions. How do we split Overdrives / Hyperspatials / Inertial Stabilizers? And how do we split Neuts / Smartbombs?
Overdrives / Hyperspatials / Inertial Stabilizers
For the Rigs, a Hyperspatial Rig will always shave 4-5 seconds of your total warp time, while any kind of Astronautics Rig will change the reapproach time by less than that, so the Rigs should always be Hyperspatials.
The Lowslots are a little bit more nuanced. Just straight up going for reapproach speed a 4 / 2 split of Overdrives / Inertials gives the highest base speed (I considered Nanofibers but they are worse because of stacking penalties). Each Hyperspatial will generally save you about 1.5 seconds in warp time, while the last Overdrive will give you about 1.5 seconds as well if you spawn at 15km, gradually decreasing. If you assume that the mean spawn distance is 10km and the standard deviation is 2.5km (My assumption, I would love to see actual data on that) then this will result in about 0.7 seconds on average – clearly a single Hyperspatial is ok. For the second one the time delta at 15km is already 3 seconds and the average is about 1.5, making either option a good choice. I went with the Overdrive because I think reapproaching might be a little bit more important.
Neuts / Smartbombs
Warp Disruption Probes have 1000 HP and a Smartbomb does 300 damage – this means that you would need to have 4 Smartbombs to reliably clear a Bubble in 1 cycle or 2 for 2 cycles. T2 Smartbombs are not that good since they have a “Dead Zone” between 5 and 6km of the wormhole where you can’t jump, nor Smartbomb and warp away, and as T1s do less damage you should always use meta Smartbombs. It is hard to find out, if giving up 2 or 4 slots on a Roller to maybe Smartbomb a Bubble is worth it, as it relies a lot on where the Bubble is.
I would argue that typically a Sabre warps to the hole at 0 (2.5km deviation up to either side, assumed equal possibility) and drops a Bubble, while you are approaching. You will be at least 6km away (otherwise you will have enough momentum to jump with the AB). Doing some quick maths, this means that in the best case your Smartbomb radius will cover about 21.3% of all locations where the Bubbly might be – so the chance you successfully smartbomb it is about 1/5, going up with the number of rollers you have. This is not enough for me, so I go full Neuts. Initially, I had all heavy Neuts, Roxane Barviainen pointed out to me that having some Medium Neuts as well might be more useful than just all heavys. And after Roxane escaped a gank attempt from my corp with every single ship, I sat down and put some more time into it. At the moment I am in favor of a 4/2 split, as you can neut every third tick (And only with 6 Mediums you can Neut every 2nd, otherwise you get something in between). You would want to activate them in the order HHMMHH in order to get the best spread.
This is it pretty much, I added a Cap Booster each to keep the Neuts running and the Machariel has 1 more midslot, you can put pretty much whatever you want in there, it doesn’t change performance.
I put a Target Spectrum Breaker just because that module is cool. You might also want to tackle something while you die or do something else.
Roxane Barviainen (again) recently urged me to put a plate(s) on the Marchariel as the mass is too low to use it as a roller properly. Without any plates, the chance that you need a rolling HIC is over 20%! So I change the fit to include two plates, with this the chance you need a HIC goes down to 0.28%. For comparison: With the Tempests, the chance is 2%. As the addition of mass is what slows you down there is not really any way you can get a benefit from fitting a different set of plates. The only thing that could also be interesting is a single max mass abyssal plate, giving you room for another Overdrive Injector System, while increasing the chance that you need a HIC to 6.7%, but saves you another 2 seconds on your average reapproach time.
I did some basic heat optimization as well, nothing fancy, just maximizing the time you can heat the Neuts and Prop Mods, and putting modules that shouldn’t burn up further away.
Fast Rolling Tempest
[Tempest, Meta Fast Roller] Overdrive Injector System II Overdrive Injector System II Overdrive Injector System II Inertial Stabilizers II Inertial Stabilizers II Limited Hyperspatial Accelerator 500MN Quad LiF Restrained Microwarpdrive Heavy F-RX Compact Capacitor Booster, Cap Booster 3200 Large Micro Jump Drive Burst Jammer II 100MN Afterburner II Heavy Energy Neutralizer II Heavy Energy Neutralizer II Core Probe Launcher I Medium Energy Neutralizer II Medium Energy Neutralizer II Improved Cloaking Device II Heavy Energy Neutralizer II Heavy Energy Neutralizer II Large Higgs Anchor I Large Hyperspatial Velocity Optimizer I Large Hyperspatial Velocity Optimizer I Hornet EC-300 x5 Vespa EC-600 x5 Cap Booster 3200 x3 Core Scanner Probe I x16
Fast Rolling Machariel
[Machariel, Meta Fast Roller] Overdrive Injector System II Overdrive Injector System II Inertial Stabilizers II Inertial Stabilizers II 1600mm Rolled Tungsten Compact Plates 1600mm Rolled Tungsten Compact Plates 500MN Quad LiF Restrained Microwarpdrive Signature Radius Suppressor I Burst Jammer II Large Micro Jump Drive Heavy F-RX Compact Capacitor Booster, Navy Cap Booster 3200 100MN Afterburner II Heavy Energy Neutralizer II Heavy Energy Neutralizer II Improved Cloaking Device II Medium Energy Neutralizer II Medium Energy Neutralizer II Core Probe Launcher I Heavy Energy Neutralizer II Heavy Energy Neutralizer II Large Higgs Anchor I Large Hyperspatial Velocity Optimizer II Large Hyperspatial Velocity Optimizer II Hornet EC-300 x5 Vespa EC-600 x10 Navy Cap Booster 3200 x4 Sisters Core Scanner Probe x16
These ones are meant to shoot back while rolling. There is definitely a lot of possible fits, essentially just put a Higgs Rig on a normal combat Battleship. I will only cover hull tanked ships here as I believe that they can still be useful when out shipped by the enemy – they will not immediately melt and have a ton of damage to apply.
Cheap Combat Roller
The ship that suits this best is the Megathron. The High-, Lowslots and Rigs are pretty self-explanatory. The only interesting thing are the Midslots. Because there are only 4 one has to make a sacrifice. If your goal is to shoot tackle you need at least a Scram + Grapple to apply, you need an MWD for certain, and the last slot can be either an AB (making you susceptible to Neuts) or a Cap Booster (making you unable to close a Hole when scrammed). There isn’t really a good solution here. I went out for a walk on this problem, and when coming back realized that the Cap Booster is probably better: You have a way to deal with Scrams – shoot the one scramming you, but you don’t have a way to deal with Neuts. I rounded the fit off with the always useful EC-300s and a hard-to-kill CN Vespas.
Buffer Rolling Megathron
[Megathron, Combat Roller] Damage Control II Magnetic Field Stabilizer II Magnetic Field Stabilizer II Reinforced Bulkheads II Reinforced Bulkheads II Reinforced Bulkheads II Reinforced Bulkheads II Reinforced Bulkheads II 500MN Y-T8 Compact Microwarpdrive Heavy F-RX Compact Capacitor Booster, Navy Cap Booster 800 Warp Scrambler II Heavy Gunnar Compact Stasis Grappler Neutron Blaster Cannon II Neutron Blaster Cannon II Neutron Blaster Cannon II Neutron Blaster Cannon II Neutron Blaster Cannon II Neutron Blaster Cannon II Neutron Blaster Cannon II Large Higgs Anchor I Large Transverse Bulkhead I Large Transverse Bulkhead I Caldari Navy Vespa x5 Hornet EC-300 x5 Null L x2000 Void L x2000 Navy Cap Booster 800 x10 Caldari Navy Antimatter Charge L x1000 Core Scanner Probe I x16 Mobile Depot x1 Agency 'Pyrolancea' DB5 Dose II x1 Standard Drop Booster x1 Core Probe Launcher I x1
Maximum Capability Combat Roller
If you don’t like the tradeoff that must be made with the Midslots of the Megathron and want to catch people by surprise, then you might want to look at the Dominix Navy. Not a lot of people know that this ship is actually a Roller, but it actually is! For about 300m more than the Megathron you can get an absolutely silly roller, which gets about the same DPS, but 2 more Midslots (making it possible to circumvent the tradeoffs) and twice as much EHP.
Combat Rolling Dominix Navy Issue
[Dominix Navy Issue, Combat Roller] Reinforced Bulkheads II Reinforced Bulkheads II Reinforced Bulkheads II Reinforced Bulkheads II Reinforced Bulkheads II Reinforced Bulkheads II Damage Control II 500MN Quad LiF Restrained Microwarpdrive 100MN Afterburner II Warp Scrambler II Stasis Webifier II Heavy Stasis Grappler II Medium Capacitor Booster II, Navy Cap Booster 800 Neutron Blaster Cannon II Neutron Blaster Cannon II Neutron Blaster Cannon II Neutron Blaster Cannon II Neutron Blaster Cannon II Neutron Blaster Cannon II Large Transverse Bulkhead II Large Transverse Bulkhead II Large Higgs Anchor I Acolyte II x5 Caldari Navy Wasp x5 Hammerhead II x5 Ogre II x5 Vespa EC-600 x5 Warrior II x5 Null L x2000 Void L x2000 Navy Cap Booster 800 x8 Caldari Navy Antimatter Charge L x1000 Sisters Core Scanner Probe x16 Mobile Depot x1 Agency 'Pyrolancea' DB5 Dose II x1 Standard Drop Booster x1 Core Probe Launcher I x1
The idea seems to be common that you put some kind of combination of tank and speed modules on your Roller, making them be able to “coast” to the wormhole while tanking the incoming DPS. There seem to be a lot of different ways that people do this. Some people tank their Tempests / Machariels and give up some speed, while other people fit speed mods on their slow Megathrons.
I thought the only real way to evaluate ships is to look at different Scram + Webs scenarios and calculate the time that it takes to get to the wormhole so that we can calculate the maximum DPS that can come in. I decided to make a spreadsheet (you can find all the fits above in there). Since distance dependent on time has an exponential and a proportional factor (formula from an archived Eve Wiki page, integrate with respect to t from 0 to t to get the distance) and I didn’t want to deal with Riemann-Zeta functions for this, I decided to do an approximate VLOOKUP() in the spreadsheet, I then use the same mean and standard deviation in jump ranges that I used earlier to determine a weighted average.
While trying a few fits I realized that the (so far) best one is a max tanked Megathron, fitting one Speed Mod already reduces the average DPS you can tank in almost all scenarios. This optimal coaster fit will take a long time to get back to the hole, so maybe this isn’t too realistic if you consider bumping.
Nonetheless, I decided to stick with it and go all-in on stuff that can reduce your time to get back to the hole, namely a Burst Jammer, Neuts, and Noses so that you can keep your AB going no matter what and try to shed Webs / Scrams. There is probably a better active tanked fit for when you are under 2+ Webs as this one only tanks 650 DPS in that Scenario, but for the other 4 Scenarios, it is pretty good (the Combat Dominix Navy fit also gets good performance in this scenario). Again this whole thing falls apart anyway when you get bumped away from your Hole, so don’t take this too seriously.
|Average Return Time (s)||Average DPS Tank|
|MWD + 1 Web||88||2572|
|MWD + 2 Web||155||1400|
|AB + 1 Web||175||1254|
|AB + 2 Web||350||649|
Cheap Coaster Megathron
[Megathron, Cheap Coaster] Damage Control II Reinforced Bulkheads II Reinforced Bulkheads II Reinforced Bulkheads II Reinforced Bulkheads II Reinforced Bulkheads II Reinforced Bulkheads II Reinforced Bulkheads II 500MN Y-T8 Compact Microwarpdrive Burst Jammer II Large Micro Jump Drive 100MN Afterburner II Heavy Ghoul Compact Energy Nosferatu Core Probe Launcher I /OFFLINE Heavy Gremlin Compact Energy Neutralizer Heavy Gremlin Compact Energy Neutralizer Heavy Gremlin Compact Energy Neutralizer Prototype Cloaking Device I Heavy Ghoul Compact Energy Nosferatu Large Higgs Anchor I Large Transverse Bulkhead I Large Transverse Bulkhead I Hornet EC-300 x5 Vespa EC-600 x5 Core Scanner Probe I x16
So we have seen that there are a few ways you can run your rolling ships, each having its own advantages and disadvantages. I am pretty happy with the Fast and Combat Rollers, but I don’t quite like the coaster fit – there just has to some better active tanked solution for that exact problem.
I personally run the fast Tempest, just because we have 2m Mass holes, and every Corp member has 3+ Accounts. This makes us able to roll rather quickly, for example, yesterday we had a ~10 man Drekavac fleet in our Static, a Sabre on our hole, and a Scout in our hole. Nonetheless, we were able to crit the hole with 3 Tempests, though admittedly one died – we tried to warp it instead of MJDing out. But maybe I will take a look at those Dominix Navies as well.